Rosland Capital vs Lear Capital: Who Wins for 2024?

By Jonah Ellingson

Disclaimer: This is not financial advice. We recommend consulting with a professional for guidance specific to your situation. We may earn a small referral fee for some of the companies mentioned in this post.

Investing in precious metals has been a steadfast strategy for those looking to diversify their investment portfolio and safeguard their retirement savings against economic volatility.

The decision to invest in metals like gold, silver, platinum, and palladium can significantly impact the growth and security of your assets.

However, the pivotal factor in this equation is selecting the right precious metals dealer. Two standout companies in this sector are Rosland Capital and Lear Capital. B

oth offer a variety of products and services, but it’s essential to understand their differences and similarities to make an informed choice that aligns with your investment goals.

Key Highlights

  • Diverse Investment Options: Both Rosland Capital and Lear Capital offer a wide range of precious metals products, including IRA-eligible coins and exclusive offerings, catering to collectors and investors alike.
  • Transparent Fees and Charges: Understanding the fee structure for Gold IRA services is crucial, with Rosland Capital providing a clear breakdown and Lear Capital offering benefits for large-scale investors.
  • Reputation and Customer Feedback: Rosland Capital enjoys a solid online reputation with positive customer feedback, while Lear Capital faces mixed reviews, emphasizing the importance of due diligence when selecting a precious metals dealer.

Company Overviews

Rosland Capital

  • Founded in 2008 by Marin Aleksove, Rosland Capital has carved a niche in the precious metals industry, offering an extensive range of products and gold IRAs to customers.
  • It prides itself on being a premier source of gold, silver, platinum, and palladium, providing customers access to both IRA-eligible products and exclusive specialty coins.
  • Rosland Capital has forged strategic partnerships with entities like Formula 1, the PGA Tour, and the British Museum to offer 100% exclusively licensed coins, showcasing their commitment to quality and collector value.

Lear Capital

  • Declaring itself as America’s Precious Metals Leader since 1997, Lear Capital focuses on the long-term financial security of its customers.
  • The company offers a wide array of products, including bullion, premium rare coins, and options for adding physical gold and silver to existing IRA accounts.
  • With Lear Capital, investors gain access to a personal account representative, a secure ordering environment, and timely updates on precious metals news and economic events that could influence their retirement and future.

Product Offerings

Rosland Capital Products

  • Offers a variety of IRA-eligible products such as the American Buffalo Gold coin and American Eagle Gold and Silver proofs.
  • Features exclusive coins like the Billie Jean King Cup 2022 1.5 oz Gold Coin and the Arnold Palmer 2.5 oz Silver Proof 2022, among others.

Lear Capital Products

  • Provides a comprehensive selection of gold, silver, and platinum products, catering to both collectors and investors.
  • Some notable offerings include:
    • Gold Products: $10 Liberty Gold coin (circulated), $20 Gold Liberty, and Canadian Maple Leaf gold coins.
    • Silver Products: American Eagle Silver coin, Morgan Silver Dollar, and Silver Rounds.
    • Platinum Products: Platinum Bar 1 oz, Platinum Canadian Maple Leaf, and Platinum American Eagle.

Gold IRA Services

Rosland Capital Gold IRA

Setting up a Gold IRA with Rosland Capital involves:

  • An initial discussion with a representative to understand how precious metals IRAs work.
  • Completing paperwork and establishing an account, followed by the selection of metals for your IRA.
  • Coordination for the purchase and secure storage of metals at the Delaware depository.
  • Transparent fee structure with no charges for setting up a precious metal IRA, but standard fees for administration and storage apply.

Lear Capital Gold IRA

Lear Capital offers the Lear Advantage IRA:

  • Focuses on investing in quality precious metals.
  • Provides benefits like free IRA setup and storage, a free gold and silver guide, a price match guarantee, and a 24-hour risk-free purchase guarantee.
  • Encourages investors to open a new IRA account via their website, promising a straightforward and beneficial process for diversifying your investment portfolio.

Both companies offer Gold IRA services that allow investors to physically hold gold and silver in a self-directed IRA account, providing a secure way to protect and grow your retirement savings.

Fees and Charges Comparison

When it comes to investing in a Gold IRA, understanding the fee structure of Rosland Capital and Lear Capital is crucial for investors. These fees can significantly affect the long-term growth of your investment, making it vital to consider them before making a decision.

Rosland Capital:

  • Does not charge customers any fees for establishing a precious metal IRA, but investors must pay fees to Equity Institutional.
  • The fee breakdown includes:
    • A one-time $50 setup fee.
    • A $100 annual maintenance fee.
    • Storage fees of $100 or $150 per year, based on the storage option chosen.
    • A $40 fee for paper statements, though digital copies are available at no cost.

Lear Capital:

  • Charges a flat annual fee for self-directed IRAs, with the first-year fee being $280, covering storage fees and an insurance policy for your precious metals.
  • The fee drops to $200 from the second year onwards.
  • Lear Capital offers to cover some or all of the yearly fees depending on the investment amount, with varying levels of fee waivers for investments over $10,000, $25,000, $50,000, and $75,000.

The comparison reveals that both companies offer competitive fees, but Lear Capital presents additional benefits for investors who commit a substantial amount of assets, potentially making it a more favorable option for those planning to invest heavily in precious metals.

Online Ratings and Customer Feedback

Rosland Capital

  • Rosland Capital is an A+ BBB accredited business with a 4.71/5 rating by customers.
  • The company has seen 34 complaints closed in the last 3 years, with customer reviews highlighting the attentive and informative nature of representatives, ensuring investors feel comfortable and well-informed about their investment choices.
  • However, there have been complaints regarding the buy-back process and pricing of metals, indicating areas where potential investors may need clarification.

Lear Capital

  • Lear Capital is not BBB accredited and has a rating of 2.65/5 based on 17 reviews.
  • The company faced significant challenges, as evidenced by its reorganization under Chapter 11 of the federal Bankruptcy Act in 2022.
  • Customer feedback for Lear Capital is mixed, with some highlighting issues with guidance on retirement portfolios and dissatisfaction with the handling of transactions and pricing.

The online reputation and customer feedback for both companies show a clear contrast, with Rosland Capital generally receiving more positive reviews compared to Lear Capital. It’s essential for potential investors to consider these aspects when choosing a precious metals dealer.

Conclusion: Which is Best for Investors?

Choosing between Rosland Capital and Lear Capital for your precious metals investment comes down to personal preference and specific investment goals. Both companies offer a range of products and services aimed at helping investors diversify their portfolios and secure their retirement savings.

  • Rosland Capital offers a wide variety of exclusive and IRA-eligible products, making it a compelling choice for collectors and investors interested in unique offerings. The company’s strong online ratings and customer service feedback further solidify its reputation as a reliable dealer in the precious metals market.
  • Lear Capital emphasizes its commitment to long-term financial security, offering personalized services and benefits for large-scale investors. However, potential investors should be mindful of the company’s recent financial reorganization and mixed customer reviews.

In conclusion, Rosland Capital may be the superior choice for investors looking for a diverse array of precious metal offerings and a company with a solid reputation. On the other hand, Lear Capital might appeal to those prioritizing IRA services and potentially larger investments, provided they are comfortable with the company’s current standing and customer feedback. Ultimately, engaging with representatives from both companies for further information will help refine your decision, ensuring it aligns with your investment strategy and goals.


What are the benefits of investing in a Gold IRA?

Investing in a Gold IRA provides several advantages, including:

  • Diversification of your investment portfolio, reducing the risk associated with market volatility.
  • Protection against inflation, as the value of gold often increases when the cost of living does.
  • Potential for long-term growth, as gold and other precious metals have historically appreciated over time.
  • Offers a tangible asset within your retirement account.

How do I choose between Rosland Capital and Lear Capital?

Choosing between Rosland Capital and Lear Capital involves considering several factors:

  • Product offerings: Evaluate the range and type of products available that meet your investment criteria.
  • Fees and charges: Understand the fee structure for Gold IRA services and how they might impact your investment.
  • Customer service and support: Consider the quality of customer service based on online ratings and feedback.
  • Company reputation: Research the company’s standing in the industry and any recent developments that might affect its stability.
  • Your investment goals and the amount you plan to invest.

Are there any hidden fees to be aware of?

Both Rosland Capital and Lear Capital maintain a transparent fee structure for their Gold IRA services. However, it’s crucial to:

  • Ask for a detailed breakdown of all potential fees, including setup, maintenance, storage, and any transactional fees.
  • Inquire about any conditions that might lead to additional charges in the future.
  • Understand the terms related to buying back metals and any associated costs.

Can I transfer an existing IRA into a Gold IRA?

Yes, you can transfer an existing IRA into a Gold IRA with both Rosland Capital and Lear Capital. This process typically involves:

  • Opening a new Gold IRA account with your chosen dealer.
  • Completing a transfer request form to move funds from your existing IRA to the new Gold IRA.
  • Selecting the precious metals to include in your new IRA. It’s a straightforward process that both companies can assist with, ensuring a seamless transition to diversify your retirement savings with precious metals.

Jonah Ellingson

About the author

Jonah has worked as a professional journalist for more than a decade. He carries a B.A. in broadcast journalism and a Masters in Education from the University of Montana. His primary focus is on gold and silver IRAs, as well as all news and trending topics related to gold and silver investing. When he's not busy researching or writing, he can usually be found on a golf course.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}